In-plant examinations along with laboratory evaluations of tube support plate intersections removed from operating plants have indicated that the tube denting phenomena, i.e., reduction of tube ID, is related to the corrosion of the carbon steel tube support plate.1  The corrosion of the carbon steel within the annular spacing between the Inconel Alloy 600* tubing and the carbon steel support plate produces a magnetite deposit (Fe3O4) that is more voluminous than the parent metal and contain chloride ions. The large volume increase resulting from the conversion of the parent metal to in situ magnetite within the tube/tube support plate annular gap cause large radial forces to be exerted on the Inconel Alloy 600 tubing. These large forces are responsible for the observed denting phenomena in some of the operating steam generators.

You do not currently have access to this content.