In the fall of 1975, field data from two nuclear power plants indicated a reduction in the diameters of Inconel 600 steam generator tubes at their intersections within the tube support plates.1  The affected plants had operated for a long time on a phosphate water chemistry (13 to 15 months) and were subsequently switched to an all volatile treatment (AVT) using ammonia and hydrazine. Shortly after the switch to AVT (3 to 6 months), reductions in tube diameter, or "denting", were observed. At that time, the long phosphate chemistry prehistory was considered to be significant, since plants with little or no phosphate history were not denting. It was also considered significant that the plants that were experiencing denting used sea water or brackish water for condenser cooling and were therefore susceptible to higher, and more acid, levels of chloride contamination from condenser inleakage than fresh water plants. However, denting has been observed recently in plants that have had no phosphate history.

You do not currently have access to this content.